Category Archives: ET

Love in Rambo Style

In Nagesh Kukunoor’s Bollywood Calling, Om Puri explains to
the frustrated Hollywood import that ‘we Indians want all the
emotions in a single movie’. Desamuduru is one such a movie
with a bonus-a hero in six-pack splendor. Ever saw a ‘Rambo’
romance n’ dance? In Desamuduru you do.

Puri Jagan has come to be known as a man who defies tradition.
He takes this defiance to an all-time high, by making his hero fall
for a Sanyasin. After taking this unconventional story idea and
setting the love track against the picturesque Kullu-Manali, he
retracts to a rather predictable action-filled-love-story kind of
narration. While, the first half is all about how the hero wins
over heroine’s heart, the second is about getting her back in
‘sahi-salamath’ shape. In short, it is the usual Puri Jagan’s
hero characterization, replete with pithy one-liners and
truckloads of violence.

Puri Jagan could have come up with a different fare had he
explored the premise of a Sanyasin abandoning her path and
narrated the film from the heroine’s point of view. Instead he
uses this as a sidetrack for the film-like an obvious ploy to
make the heroine an impossible-to-get-item. Similarities to
the Hindi movie Paap are there to be seen with Allu Arjun
sporting a John Abraham avatar and Hansika dressed as
a modern Sanyasin. But the ensuing conflict is the usual
Puri Jagan’s fare, with the hero going all out to woo his girl.
When he finally succeeds in ‘spoiling’ her, as Ramaprabha
observes, it is our Desi Rambo all the way.

Infact, the transition scene from Kullu-Manali to Hyderabad
is a defining one (though inspired from Lock, Stock and
Two Smoking Barrels) where the hero receives a call in mid-air
from the villain and unlike in the original movie, picks it up and
‘loudly’ announces his plans for the second-half. Loudness is
the defining characteristic of Desamuduru, and luckily for the
entire unit, the movie is screaming loud at the box-office too.

While congratulating Puri Jagan for setting the box-office on
fire, here are some issues worth pondering in the main plot.

Is the heroine after all so difficult to get?

She becomes a Sanyasin not by her will, but by design. So,
she is on tenterhooks to begin with and may be even ready to
break loose with any hero in the near proximity. Hence, for all
practical purposes, Puri’s regular, Ravi Teja, would have sufficed…
did she really need a six-pack Allu Arjun?

Eternal love or carnal love?

A Sanyasin is supposed to renounce the real world and the
denial of flesh is a step towards it. Now if she has made up her
mind to shun the bodily pleasures and if she has to think otherwise,
she has to experience them first. However, she does not. As the
film has to appeal to a large audience, this aspect has been left to
the wind and as a result becomes the usual
‘sweet-love-with-no-touch-till-marriage’ kind. Ok…now, if their love
is not carnal and their bond is eternal, then bodies don’t matter,
time does not matter, etc., etc. Then what necessitates all those
conversations about ‘matti, mannu, masanam’ etc.

Hmm..agreed that the audiences have ignored the so-called
minor issues with the plot and gave a clean chit to Puri Jagan.
Or they might have been carried away by the enthusiasm of
Allu Arjun, or the freshness of Hansika or the foot-tapping
music or the neat cinematography. But will these come to
the story teller’s rescue every often when he takes the so
called cinematic liberties with the so called bold/unconventional
themes and still yield the same result at the box-office?

Well, we might have to wait till the Ramcharan’s film hits the marquee.

For the time being, let’s agree with Mr. Om Puri and accept
Puri Jagan as a master in such genre. Coming to
Nagesh Kukunoor,…he just announced his next film with
John Abraham.

Now will it be a Paap kind, sans the Desamuduru’s effervescence?

Well, that’s another wait!!

* * * * * * * * * * * * *
Also featured in

Citizen GuruKant

Thakur: Nahi jailer sahab, agar ek taraf in me ye sab kharaabiyaa hai to doosari taraf kuchh khubiyaa bhi hai.
Jailer: Khota sikka to dono hi taraf se khota hota hai.
Thakur: Sikke aur insaa me shayad yehi fark hai….
(From ‘Sholay’)

It is this ‘Fark’ that Maniratnam brings to the fore in the characterization of ‘Gurukanth Desai’, his starry-eyed protagonist. And inspite of all the ‘kharaabiyan’ his detractors find in his approach of running a business, Guru marches on and emerges a winner. Maniratnam takes all the contrasting views on Gurukanth Desai and weaves an endearing tale, almost attempting a Citizen Kane. But he stays away from the darker side of the force and just when things start to become a little heavy and megalomaniac for Bollywood standards, he pulls ‘Guru’ back rather abruptly to a predictable ending. And the story moves out of the movie as Gurubhai’s unexplained and enigmatic legacy.

 

Coming to the story of the movie, it deals with the five phases of Guru’s life.

  • The formative years and breaking away from tradition.
  • Riding a flight of fancy and chasing a dream.
  • Rising over the peers.
  • Battling with his detractors.
  • Emerging invincible and in the process become larger than life.

While Maniratnam and his crew shine in the first three, it is Abhishek Bachchan all the way in the last two. Infact it is his stellar performance that saves the second half which is a tad weak and monotonous compared to the first. Fortunately, Abhishek peaks at the right time to carry the rest of the movie on his shoulders. It is as if he emerges from his Guru, Maniratnam’s shadows.

It is given that technical standards are noteworthy in Maniratnam’s films. But ‘Guru’ raises the bar in production design, cinematography and audiography, all of them well blended into story telling. Whether it is the remote village in Gujarat or the dance hall that showcases Mallika Sherawat, or the bustling streets of Mumbai, the trio of Samir Chanda (Production Design), Rajiv Menon (Cinematography) and H. Sridhar (Audiography) succeed in creating an immersion factor for the audience. In particular Maniratnam uses the street set of Mumbai to good effect before the song sequence of ‘Tere Bina’.

Speaking of songs, there is not much to mention. AR Rahman comes with an average effort and his songs come as speed breakers to narration especially in the second half. But, he redeems himself with a memorable background score, and the theme of Guru haunts you long after you leave the movie theatre.

There has been some talk about the story based on the life of Dhirubhai Ambani and the likes. But as the movie progresses into second half, Maniratnam steers away from this line and creates an Ayn Rand’s The Fountainhead kind of power-battle with Mithun Chakraborty, Madhavan, Abhishek Bachchan and Vidya Balan at the vertices. As ‘Guru’ is bombarded with lot of facts and morals, the story telling becomes rather technical and internalized. But Abhishek’s performance takes your mind away from all these and his aplomb carries you away, specially in the climax which is molded on the lines of The Godfather Part II.

The rest of the star cast headed by Aishwarya Rai is adequate and fits nicely into the journey of ‘Guru’. In a biopic kind of a movie, you can never really cover every angle, but two aspects are quite glaring. One is the absence of a steady competitor in Guru’s line of business and the missing conflict. Second, there is no consistent portrayal of Guru’s people management, vital in a business leader’s growth. But these could be brushed away as minor looking at the ground covered already.

In the end ‘Guru’ is a thourougly watchable fare with lot of ‘khubiyaa’. Enjoy it in a multiplex near you. (In ordinary theatres the sound mixing is just not right).

* * * * * * * * *
Also featured in

Related links
Laksh on Maniratnam’s Guru
Guru’s official site

One Soldier. Battles Galore

 

Prince Mahesh Babu’s latest Sainikudu is a mishmash of the
worst kind, replete with hackneyed scenes, dialogues, monologues,
situations, fights, songs and special EFXs.

Interestingly the prized talent of Indian Cinema adds their might
to this mishmash. The who’s who list include Trisha, Prakash Raj,
Irfan Khan, Paruchuri brothers, Peter Hein, Harris Jayraj..and the
gang leaders-Aswani Dutt and Gunasekhar. Well, getting all these
big names to work together is a history of sorts. But, the movie
itself might be in danger of becoming a history-a thing of past-at
the box-office pretty soon.

Coming back to the mishmash. How could you possibly make
mishmash worse?

Sainikudu seems to offer a step-by-step guide by mounting
every borrowed aspect of cinema on a huge canvass. Let it be
a simple scene where the friends discuss their next move against
a sprawling city skyline or when the heroine fancies herself with
a Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon act in a thick jungle-both are
set in enviable surroundings. And, you know what? Both these
scenes are digitally touched to international standards.

Now, if the producer-director duo has taken such a ‘meticulous
care’ with simple scenes would they desert the all-important songs
and action sequences? Nope! They summon dolphins in the clouds
and make fishes swim in the air in a dream song. And they spread
the battlefield of their Sainikudu with mines and bridges-both
ready to get blasted.

In the midst of all though, they forgot some minor details like
getting an original score from Harris Jayraj or providing some
rationale for the hero to perform the rescue acts in the battlefield
or alteast clarify on the geography. This leaves the star Mahesh Babu
and his character in the movie hanging in the air, rather literally.
In the end, though he effortlessly comes victorious as a video-game
warrior on screen, he makes us wonder if there are any battles off
screen. Here are a few of them.

For starters, he is up against a weak script. The word script is
almost a misnomer in the cinema these days, so let’s call it a thread
around a central idea that joins all those myriad of scenes, action
sequences, songs and loads of special EFX. And that’s hard to find
in the movie. Right from the beginning of the movie the hero is
hurled into every possible danger and he comes unscathed almost
like a Bhakta Prahlada amidst weak representation of the
Hiranyakashyapa, Lord Vishnu and Prahlada’s devotion.

Drawing parallels to Sainikudu, Irfan Khan/Prakash Raj, Hero’s
mission and Hero’s angst/his desire are not etched out properly.
If this is not enough, you have a very unusual love quadrangle
between Irfan Khan, Trisha, Mahesh Babu and Mahesh Babu’s
mission. So, every time he gets into fight, or engages in a duel
with Irfan Khan/Trisha the normal cinegoers heave a sigh, while
the nicotine friendly/bladder weak take a stroll into the park.

Second, he battles cinegoer’s ‘Hey-we-have-seen-it-somewhere’
and ‘Hey-where-is-Mahesh’s-trademark-stuff’ syndromes. A dozen
movies like Aparichutudu, Rang De Basanti, Yuva, Okkadu, etc.,
form the first syndrome. Recent blockbusters like Athadu and
Pokiri result in the second. And Sainikudu does not succeed in
getting rid of these syndromes through out the movie. When it
comes to first syndrome it goes overboard and with the second,
it falls short.

Third, he faces the mother of all battles-ala Frankenstein-the hype
that’s been unleashed by the makers. Right from the audio launch
the movie grabbed news headlines and as a result the expectations
soared. Now how could anyone match the expectations of people
who haven’t sampled the product yet? This becomes a Herculean
mission even for a broad shouldered, successful star like Mahesh Babu.

The makers should have taken some inspiration from UTV’s
Web 2.0 kind of marketing style of Rang De Basanti that encouraged
and involved target community participation. UTV first let the community
lap up the film and then made them talk, rather than resort to a
broadcast to everyone kind. Sadly, Sainikudu’s makers adopt the
second. This once again alludes to a weak script and the central idea
going for a toss.

While the box-office fate of Sainikudu has not emerged yet,
one thing seems certain. Prince Mahesh Babu has to overcome a
roadblock or two before he is crowned as the King of Tollywood.

And there are a zillion of cinegoers who want to seen him as the King soon.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *

Also Featured in

Related links

Laksh on Sainikudu